A hormone that seems to promote monogamy and parenting in people may also make us more likely to cooperate with others, even in risky situations. Research in rodents shows while the hormone, called AVP (arginine vasopressin), promotes bonding, it also boosts aggression in males.
Says Colin Camerer, a professor of behavioral economics at Caltech;
“Part of the dark side of monogamy is that an AVP-pumped-up male is more likely to behave aggressively toward intruders,”
Camerer wanted to test the idea that AVP could help explain our species’ cooperative tendencies.
“One of the reasons humans rule the world rather than apes is that we do things that require a great deal of trust. We cooperate in large-scale groups,” Camerer says. “Where does that come from? Is it something like pair bonding but just scaled up? And if it is, what role does AVP play?”
To investigate these questions, Camerer and his colleagues administered a nasal spray containing AVP or a hormone-free nasal spray (a placebo) to 59 male volunteers, aged 19 to 32 years old. Pairs of subjects then used computers to play a so-called assurance game in which they had to choose whether or not to cooperate with another player; “assurance” comes from the fact that subjects will take a risky action if they are sufficiently assured that others will, too.
When they cooperated, both players received more points than they would have if they did not mutually cooperate. If one player chose not to cooperate but his partner made the opposite decision, the non-cooperative player received an intermediate payoff whereas the cooperative player received nothing.
“The game is designed to mimic situations in which people are willing to help, but only if everyone else helps too,” Camerer says. “Think of pitching in on a team project, or of a group of soldiers rushing the enemy. If a critical mass cooperates, then everyone else should go along. Thus it is in your best interest to help only if enough others do.”
To help ensure the players were engaged, the points they accumulated were converted into actual money at the end of the game (usually around $20).
Makes People More Cooperative
The experiment showed that players who received AVP before the game were significantly more likely to cooperate than those who received the placebo.
“By targeting a specific hormonal system in the human brain, we could manipulate people’s willingness to cooperate and help them do better,” says Gideon Nave, a graduate student in Camerer’s lab and a coauthor on the study.
Using control experiments, the researchers were also able to rule out other explanations for why the subjects were cooperating. For example, one possibility is that AVP was increasing the subjects’ appetite for risks. Alternatively, the administered hormone might be amplifying their altruistic tendencies, so that they just wanted to help other people regardless of the risk to themselves.
“We found that when we asked them, ‘Do you want to just give some money to this stranger?’ they don’t do it,” Camerer says. “So AVP seems to be quite specialized to this particular type of risky cooperation.”
What Brain Scans Show
To better understand the neural mechanism underlying AVP’s effect on risky cooperation, the researchers conducted the same experiment but this time had subjects—a separate group of 34 men—play the game while their brains were being imaged using a functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) scanner.
The scans indicated that after AVP administration, a part of the brain’s reward system known as the ventral pallidum—a region that is known to have an abundance of AVP receptors—showed a change in neural activity when the players decided to cooperate.
“That was very encouraging, because it showed that the hormone is activating a part of the brain that is known to be rich in AVP receptors,” Camerer says.
Could the discovery that AVP increases the likelihood of risky cooperation have practical applications and be used, for example, to engender trust and foster cooperation in groups? Perhaps.
“You could imagine a high-stakes situation, such as a military operation, in which people have to trust each other to all do something difficult and it fails if anyone chickens out,” Camerer says. “In that case, you might want to administer AVP to help ensure that everyone is cooperative.”
Brunnlieb, Claudia and Nave, Gideon and Camerer, Colin F. and Schosser, Stephan and Vogt, Bodo and Münte, Thomas F. and Heldmann, Marcus (2016)
Vasopressin increases human risky cooperative behavior
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America; doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1518825113
Photo: Jan Ramroth/Flickr