A reorganisation of the wiring of the brain is the underlying cause of phantom limb pain, researchers have discovered. A potential method of treating the phenomenon, which occurs in the vast majority of individuals who have had limbs amputated, has also been identified, using artificial intelligence techniques.
The researchers, led by a group from Osaka University in Japan in collaboration with the University of Cambridge, used a brain-machine interface to train a group of ten individuals to control a robotic arm with their brains. They found that if a patient tried to control the prosthetic by associating the movement with their missing arm, it increased their pain, but training them to associate the movement of the prosthetic with the unaffected hand decreased their pain.
The results demonstrate that in patients with chronic pain associated with amputation or nerve injury, there are ‘crossed wires’ in the part of the brain associated with sensation and movement, and that by mending that disruption, the pain can be treated. The findings could also be applied to those with other forms of chronic pain, including pain due to arthritis.
Around 5,000 amputations are carried out in the UK every year. Individuals with type 1 or type 2 diabetes are at particular risk of needing an amputation.
In most cases, individuals who have had a hand or arm amputated, or who have had severe nerve injuries which result in a loss of sensation in their hand, continue to feel the existence of the affected hand as if it were still there. Between 50 and 80 percent of these patients suffer with chronic pain in the ‘phantom’ hand, known as phantom limb pain.
Co-author Dr Ben Seymour, a neuroscientist based in Cambridge’s Department of Engineering, said:
“Even though the hand is gone, people with phantom limb pain still feel like there’s a hand there. It basically feels painful, like a burning or hypersensitive type of pain, and conventional painkillers are ineffective in treating it. We wanted to see if we could come up with an engineering-based treatment as opposed to a drug-based treatment.”
A popular theory of the cause of phantom limb pain is faulty ‘wiring’ of the sensorimotor cortex, the part of the brain that is responsible for processing sensory inputs and executing movements. In other words, there is a mismatch between a movement and the perception of that movement.
In the study, Seymour and his colleagues, led by Takufumi Yanagisawa from Osaka University, used a brain-machine interface to decode the neural activity of the mental action needed for a patient to move their ‘phantom’ hand, and then converted the decoded phantom hand movement into that of a robotic neuroprosthetic using artificial intelligence techniques.
“We found that the better their affected side of the brain got at using the robotic arm, the worse their pain got,” said Yanagisawa. “The movement part of the brain is working fine, but they are not getting sensory feedback – there’s a discrepancy there.”
The researchers then altered their technique to train the ‘wrong’ side of the brain.
For example, a patient who was missing their left arm was trained to move the prosthetic arm by decoding movements associated with their right arm, or vice versa. When they were trained in this counter-intuitive technique, the patients found that their pain significantly decreased.
As they learned to control the arm in this way, it takes advantage of neuroplasticity, the ability of the brain to restructure and learn new things, of the sensorimotor cortex, showing a clear link between plasticity and pain.
Although the results are promising, Seymour warns that the effects are temporary, and require a large, expensive piece of medical equipment to be effective. However, he believes that a treatment based on their technique could be available within five to ten years.
“Ideally, we’d like to see something that people could have at home, or that they could incorporate with physio treatments,” he said. “But the results demonstrate that combining AI techniques with new technologies is a promising avenue for treating pain, and an important area for future UK-Japan research collaboration.”
Takufumi Yanagisawa, Ryohei Fukuma, Ben Seymour, Koichi Hosomi, Haruhiko Kishima, Takeshi Shimizu, Hiroshi Yokoi, Masayuki Hirata, Toshiki Yoshimine, Yukiyasu Kamitani & Youichi Saitoh
Induced sensorimotor brain plasticity controls pain in phantom limb patients
Nature Communications Article number: 13209 (2016) doi:10.1038/ncomms13209
Image: Milada Vigerova