Patience Is Enhanced By Confidence And Serotonin

A new study in mice shows a link between the brain’s chemical system and the mice’s belief about how waiting will pay off. The effect of the neuromodulator serotonin on mice’s ability to stay patient when waiting for a reward is at the core of the study, by Dr. Katsuhiko Miyazaki and Dr. Kayoko Miyazaki of the Okinawa Institute of Science and Technology Graduate University (OIST).

Serotonin is a chemical messenger that influences neuron functions. It has been linked to a wide array of behaviors encompassing mood, sleep, cravings and spontaneity.

The power of the chemical over human behavior has made it a key focus in the treatment of mental conditions such as depression by selective serotonin receptor inhibitors (SSRIs), which slow down the reabsorption of serotonin and keep it active in the brain.

“Serotonin has had a lot of study in pharmacology, and serotonergic drugs are commonly prescribed. but the role that serotonin has over behavior isn’t clear,”

said Katsuhiko Miyazaki.

Dorsal Raphe Nucleus Serotonin Neurons

The mice were trained to perform a task to obtain a food reward, placing their noses into a small hole and waiting — a behavior called a “nose poke.” After a pre-set duration, the reward was delivered.

In a previous study, the team used a method called optogenetics, a method allowing scientist to use light to stimulate specific neurons with precise timing. These neurons are genetically modified to a produce a light-sensitive protein and are then stimulated by shining light along a fiber optic implanted in the brain.

In the study, serotonin-producing neurons were optogenetically stimulated in a part of the brain called the dorsal raphe nucleus (DRN). These neurons then fired widely into the forebrain.

The result was that increasing the activity of serotonin neurons in the DRN drastically increased the amount of time mice were willing to wait for a food reward.

While the study showed that serotonin increased patience, the latest study tested whether mice respond similarly in circumstances when getting a reward was uncertain. Would mice wait for food regardless of the probability and timing of its presentation, or would they give up if they predicted a low chance of return on their time investment?

Everyone Has Their Limits

The new experiments showed there are limits to serotonin’s ability to enhance patience. Mice were given a nose-poke trial with a 75 percent chance of a reward, with a three second waiting period before the reward was delivered.

25 percent probability of reward

With a 25 percent probability of reward, the nose-poke time in no-food trials did not change even if serotonin neurons were activated (left).
But with a 75 percent reward probability, the nose-poke time during no-food trials increased when serotonin neurons were activated (right).
Credit: OIST

When these mice were subject to a no-reward outcome, their waiting time was prolonged, as expected from the previous paper. However, in tests where the chance of reward delivery following a nose-poke was 50 percent or 25 percent, increasing serotonin had no effect on the mice’s waiting time.

“The patience effect only works when the mouse thinks there is a high probability of reward,”

said Dr. Miyazaki.

They also found that serotonin stimulation made the mice to wait longer when the timing of a reward was harder to predict. In some sessions with a 75 percent chance of getting a reward, mice were rewarded after precise periods, while in other sessions, they were rewarded after randomized timing.

serotonin patience test 2

Credit: OIST

The extended waiting times by serotonin neuron stimulation were more prominent when the reward timing was randomized.

Bayesian Decision Model

To explain the results of their experiment, the team constructed a computational model to explain the experimental data. In the model, the mice were able to expect when a food reward would be delivered, and to judge when they were subject to a no-reward trial.

The model could reproduce the experimental results by assuming that serotonin affects confidence of receiving a reward when subjective confidence is high. In a 75 percent reward probability trial, for example, serotonin made the mice behave as if there was a 95 percent chance of reward.

The model also reproduced the result of timing uncertainty. When the mice were uncertain of the timing of reward delivery, it became difficult for them to judge whether they were waiting in a reward trial or no-reward trial.

Bayesian decision making model for waiting reproduces features of effects of reward probability and timing uncertainty on promotion of patience by serotonin

Bayesian decision making model for waiting reproduces features of effects of reward probability and timing uncertainty on promotion of patience by serotonin.
Credit: Katsuhiko Miyazaki, et al. CC-BY

Serotonin stimulation increased the mice’s belief that they were in a reward trial, delaying their judgment further as reward timing was less clear.

The findings show that the relationship between the activation of serotonin and subsequent behavior is highly dependent on the animals’ belief about the circumstances. These results may have implications for our understanding of how humans taking serotonin boosting drugs can also be affected.

“This could help explain why combined treatment of depression with SSRIs and Cognitive Behavior Therapy (CBT) is more effective than just SSRIs alone,” said Dr. Miyazaki. “The psychological boost of the therapy is enhanced by raised serotonin levels.”

The work was partially supported by a JSPS KAKENHI Grant-in-Aid for Young Scientists, and the Strategic Research Program for Brain Sciences by the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science, and Technology of Japan.

Katsuhiko Miyazaki, Kayoko W. Miyazaki, Akihiro Yamanaka, Tomoki Tokuda, Kenji F. Tanaka & Kenji Doya
Reward probability and timing uncertainty alter the effect of dorsal raphe serotonin neurons on patience
Nature Communications volume 9, Article number: 2048 (2018)

Top Image: serotonin crystals. Spike Walker, Wellcome Images