Is Malnutrition A Cause Or Result Of Immune Dysfunction?
The cause of death in malnourished children is more likely to be common infections, rather than starvation. A new study suggests that even with a healthy diet, defects in immune system function from birth could contribute to a malnourished state throughout life.
Researchers hypothesize that targeting immune pathways could be a new approach to reduce the poor health and mortality caused by under- and overnutrition.
First author Claire Bourke, a postdoctoral research assistant in the Centre for Genomics and Child Health at Queen Mary University of London, says:
“That traditional image of malnutrition that we’re unfortunately so familiar with, of someone wasting away, that’s just the external picture. Those height and weight defects that we see are the tip of the iceberg.
There are a whole range of pro-inflammatory conditions, impaired gut function, weakened responses to new infections, and a resulting high metabolic burden underlying them.”
The most common form of undernutrition globally is stunting. This is when children fail to achieve their full height potential.
Stunted Immune Systems
Despite looking healthy, children in developing countries who are stunted in height may also have stunted immune development, making them more vulnerable to death by common infections.
Only recently have researchers had access to technology that can accurately study immunodeficiency. Even though immune parameters in undernourished children have been looked at for decades, much of that data is outdated.
Conceptual framework for immune dysfunction as a cause and consequence of malnutrition. Bourke et al./Trends in Immunology 2016
How malnutrition and immune function are related is actually still poorly understood; however, there is wide acceptance that malnutrition comes with a range of immune problems. These include reduced numbers of white blood cells, skin and gut membranes that are easier for pathogens to break through, and malfunctioning lymph nodes.
Chicken or Egg Problem
What’s also emerging is that the relationship between malnutrition and immune dysfunction may be a bit “chicken and egg,” with both causing and being the consequence of the other. Immune dysfunction results when people consume too few calories because of lack of food or have an excess of fat and sugar in their diet.
That dysfunction is recorded in the DNA through epigenetic marks, so that if malnourished people have offspring, their children inherit an altered immune system (even after multiple generations). This altered immune system may then cause malnutrition even if children have an adequate diet.
“It’s been thought for a long time that the immune system is driving pathology, but new experimental tools have made it possible to separate out the effects of the immune system from those of the diet alone,” says Bourke.
“There are new models for environmental enteric dysfunction in mice, a growing interest in microbiota and epigenetics–all of these studies show that the more we look into the immune system, the more it has a role to play in a really wide array of physiological systems. It doesn’t just fight infection; it affects metabolism, neurological function, and growth, which are things that are also impaired in malnutrition.”
Bourke envisions a future where clinicians could generate individualized immune readouts that can identify young people most susceptible to infection as a result of malnutrition. This could reduce the burden of a leading cause of child mortality by helping those who are most vulnerable get treated more often and sooner with targeted interventions.
Some could argue that the jury is still out on the immune dysfunction-malnutrition connection. There are many studies that need to be done to fully support the case, such as comparing the developing immune systems of undernourished versus healthy children over time or determining whether restoring certain immune functions could improve the outcomes of malnutrition.
Although there remain many unanswered questions, the evidence for a causal role for immune dysfunction in malnutrition continues to grow, and the authors hope their paper will encourage questions and discussion.