“We are not saying climate change isn’t a problem for bumblebees. It is a major problem. However, these findings indicate that some bumblebees may be able to adapt if provided adequate habitat, and are largely shielded from environmental pollutants, such as pesticides.”
Since bumblebees have co-evolved with the floral resources needed for nutrition, researchers were curious how resident bumblebees were faring in the alpine regions of the Rocky Mountains. They looked specifically at changes in tongue length among resident bumblebees because this trait is intimately tied to the bee-flower relationship.
Specialists and Generalists
In general, bumblebees with longer tongues are considered “specialists” which feed on flowers with deep, long tubes, while short-tongued bumblebees are “generalists” and tend to move pollen from a variety of flowers.
Bombus sylvicola is one of two bumblebee species in the central Rocky Mountains that has responded to a decline in flowering in alpine habitats by evolving a shorter tongue, an adaptation that favors generalist feeding. (Credit: Nicole Miller-Struttman)
Researchers measured the tongue lengths of alpine bumblebee species collected between 1966 and 1980 at three alpine sites of the central Rocky Mountains and archived at the University of Colorado and other museums. They resurveyed bumblebee species in the same alpine locations between 2012 and 2014 and measured their tongue lengths.
They found that for populations of two species on three mountains, tongue length had decreased by nearly 25 percent over the 40-year period.
“A change of 25 percent over this amount of time is dramatic, especially when we take into account that this change has occurred over just 40 generations,” Galen says. “Most evolutionary change occurs on a timescale of a few hundreds, thousands or millions of years. Forty years is a timescale that happens in a human lifetime.”
When they looked at the flowers visited by the alpine bumblebee species, they found that the bees’ favorite flowers had not shifted to a shallower form, but were less prolific. Overall, they found that the total food resources available to alpine bumblebees had fallen by 60 percent since the 1970s.
Rapid Adaptation Glimmer of Hope
The scientists then examined the relative advantage of the specialists versus the generalist bumblebees in a simple environment. They found that when deep flowers are in the minority and the total flower density drops, the advantage of being a generalist increases sharply.
“Basically, it shows you can afford to be a specialist if there is enough of the plant you are specializing on,” says Ricardo Holdo, assistant professor of biological sciences.
“As you start losing resources, then that’s going to have a disproportionate impact on that specialist whose flowers are not really common to begin with; this is one of the real strengths of the study: It shows that the change in the flower population is actually exerting a selective pressure on the pollinator.”
The finding of rapid adaptation is “a glimmer of hope” for bumblebees, whose populations worldwide are declining, Galen says.
“It suggests that the findings we can manage locally, like pesticides, habitat destruction, and planting companion plants, can actually make a difference because these factors can buy pollinators time for natural selection and evolution, thus allowing the species to keep pace with the things that we can’t manage locally. They seem to be giving bumblebees ‘running shoes’ in this race against climate change.”